Very similar to my thoughts. I'll try to avoid duplication.
Good:
- The Graphics are now fantastic. Genuinely very detailed, particularly the plants.
- It has Willow trees, something the first game missed. The foliage in general is incredible.
- That brush.
- I actually always wanted a power management system to provide functional back-of-house. I'm very pleased with this feature. I've not delved enough into water yet.
- Coaster building is vastly improved from a smoothing perspective.
- The flats are gorgeous and now have smaller land areas.
- Apparently people will actually ride the pirate ship now. This used to really bother me in Planet Coaster 1.
- Scaling. Oh yes, scaling.
Bad:
- Building and editing are split.
- The path system is actually harder to use now if trying to build stairs. I hope they fix this.
- Lack or scenery choices. I'd have hoped to see more brought over from the first game, as even with constructing my own elements some pieces were missing.
- No grid-snapped pillar pieces. I used these blocks in the original to help build structures by using them to snap to. This doesn't seem to exist here.
- Station entrances and exits wont snap to the grid properly. This one is actually infuriating.
- Build/Edit being too separated is frustrating.
- Cant edit land with water in it!!?
It's a good foundation, but honestly feels unfinished. The UX is pretty clunky compared to the original. I hope future updates (of the free kind) resolve this, and the paid DLC introduces some more scenery content. I wouldn't mind paying for a package containing the remaining content from the original.
Get on the Issue Tracker. If there is a genuine bug, report it. They wont fix what they don't know about.
https://issues.frontierstore.net/
I reported
this.