The ride definately grew on me. I rode it a number of times and it got better until I rode at the front, and then it started to go down for me. Still, a brilliant addition. It adds to Alton a high quality family roller coaster. I went today (Sunday) and what was interesting were the views of the general public. As you can imagine today was less filled with enthusiasts compared with yesterday. Here's some views of the public:
"That's the best ride ever!" says 10(ish) year old girl sat at the front coming back into the station. "That's her third time on it" says who is presumably her Mum sat next to her.
"That was really clever, definately worth the wait because it really is a clever piece of kit" says two late 20s/ early 30s guys.
"Wow, that ride was utter **** until you went into the building and then it was proper sick" - 18 year old (ish) chav talking to his girlfriend, who agreed.
These three points said something to me. The children enjoy it because it's an awesome family coaster, the adults appreciate the technological side of it, and the teens/ chavs actually enjoy the drop/ backwards section because it's something different, unexpected and actually is pretty cool. The latter two took me by suprise, and I really thought Alton have nailed this on the head. I expected a lot more dissapointed people with the way this has been advertised, but I heard few negative comments. The only ones I heard were about the first half being crap and the drop section being too small. I personally hate the trims, but the coaster would go way too fast up the second climb hill otherwise, and that second airtime opportunity is quite harsh as it is, let alone if the trims weren't there (from a family perspective). Whether that's poor design, or just so that coaster has the height and the intimidation, I don't know. Someone much more intelligent than me will have to tell you that.
Personally, I like it. It's not amazing, but I love the theme and the whole Dark Forest area. The first section is dull. I personally think it is much better at the front and, with the lap bar up a notch, there are two opportunities for some fun airtime. Obviously, the drop section offers some too. I also love the feeling of having friends in the front row of other trains and being able to see each other going round the coaster, waving, at other sections of the track. I love it when that interaction happens on coasters, and it very rarely does. The backwards section is great, and I love the feeling of hysteria once the train drops and starts going backwards. Especially on Sunday with people who weren't expecting it, the feeling was pretty awesome.
Overall, fantastic addition. We heard kids saying it was better then Everest (a bit too far I reckon) but it is almost like a British equivalent. A true family ride caters for everyone, and this coaster actually seems to.
In response to the theme being a bit too 'scary' for kids, I think that option is a lot better then it seeming too kiddy for the rest of us. I think it's a perfect theme because it's eerie for everyone, no matter how old you are, but it's not 'in-your'face' scary nor innapropiate for younger riders. As I said, Alton have hit the nail on the head, and it's a pretty decent addition anyway.
As for me, it won't make my top 10. It won't be anywhere near. But, as an enthusiast, I can see it's a brilliant addition for the park and I don't think they could have got a much better reaction at all.
Did it live up to it's hype? No (but we knew it wouldn't). Do the 'general public' think it lives up to it's hype? Only time will tell, but it's looking good.
EDIT: P.S. I love Rita's new colours, she looks pretty awesome, and rides better then ever in my opinion. Dunno why, but I enjoyed that more than I have done in ages.