The best picture nominees I've seen ranked from fave to least fave (I'm watching the Post and Phantom Thread this week somewhere).
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri
Just a great, high quality film. It didn't blow me away completely, but it has great writing and acting. Not much to fault about this film, other than it not leaving a huge lasting impression on me. It was entertaining from start to finish. Funny, raw, intense and clever.
The Shape of Water
Beautiful film. Definitely not as good as Pan's Labyrinth, which is a masterpiece, but it was still a wonderful film. The plot didn't have enough to it to impress me, but the way it was made was very artsy and creative. There was a single musical-ish scene that felt out of place and corny though.
Get Out
The top 3 are all quite close to each other for me. I'm glad this was nominated because I loved it. Despite seeing it almost a year ago it stuck with me.
Dunkirk
Glad that I got to see it in IMAX because as an experience it was very impressive and intense. I bet watching it on regular TV would make it quite dull. Especially somewhere in the middle I found my attention wandering off even in IMAX.
Lady Bird
Great dialogue, great acting (especially Saoirse Ronan) but I felt that the film was too fast paced with loads of short scenes that I never truly got into it. Still a very good film, but I'm a bit surprised it was nominated for best picture. It wasn't any better than last year's The Edge of Seventeen imo.
Darkest Hour
I had low expectations but it was better than I expected. The speeches were quite well done and Gary Oldman was excellent. Still not something that I'd really love.
Call Me By Your Name
Meh. I liked the first half due to its summery feel/setting, but the second half was so boring and it could do with being at least half an hour shorter. I didn't care for the characters all that much either. A well made, but ultimately very dull film.
Some other oscar nominated films I saw:
The Florida Project
I loved this film. Better than almost all of the best picture nominees (up there with the top 3). That child actress playing the girl was so impressive and the film stayed on my mind for the next few days. Quite a sad and impactful film. Willem Dafoe's character was fab.
Coco
Perhaps my fave American film of the year (it's between Coco and Baby Driver, I clearly love music-themed films it seems). Honestly brilliant. The world building and detail in the animation is the best I've ever seen in a Pixar film and even almost rivals Studio Ghibli. The music was beautiful and the whole story was quite emotional. It's honestly up there with Toy Story 3 and Monsters Inc as my fave Pixar film. Pixar has always been a bit hit/miss for me. Films like Up, Inside Out, Wall-E and Finding Nemo, while I really like some of them, all got so much praise that it left me a bit confused.
Coco will obviously deservedly win the oscar for best animated feature, but can I just say that the animated category is absolute horse sh*te? Boss Baby? Ferdinand? I bet they would even think of nominating the Emoji Movie before they consider a non-Ghibli Japanese anime film. Last year Your Name was snubbed despite it being far better than any of the animated films of that year. At least that year had solid competition though, in this year they had no excuse. Which leads me to perhaps my fave film of the year, animated or not.
A Silent Voice
What an incredible film. It deals with bullying, self-loathing, suicide, guilt and redemption in a really beautiful and believable way. It's heartfelt and relevant. Excellent animation, voice acting and overall it stayed with me a lot, especially since deafness is not something that's covered a lot in films from what I've seen. It even has an amazing scene in Nagashima Spa Land with loads of detail. Highly recommended. How the academy would pick Boss Baby over this one is something that I'll never understand.
Overall a pretty meh film year. I much preferred 2016.