Ok, I don't think I have ever purposely double posted before, but I felt this was worthy of a new post.
Definitely a spoiler this time!
Ok, Before you read the rest of this, if you're mightily confused and have only seen what I believe is called the prism edition?, watch the 1 disc directors cut - it explains the movie one hell of a lot better... it's better than the prism edition theatrically as well in my opinion.
Right, again, before you go any further, if you have the directors cut one disc edition, it would be a good idea to reference to the following points;
51:15 (Chapter one of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - Description of tangent universe)
57:14 (Chapter two of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - Water and Metal)
62:23 (Chapter seven of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - the manipulated living)
64:02 (Donnie moves through time during Jim Cunninghams' presentation)
69:24 (Chapter four of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - The Artifact And The Living)
72:27 (Chapter six of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - The Living Receiver)
Right, I'm not sure, but I think that is all of them... if somebody knows of an other chapter in the book that is shown and I've missed, please post it.
Now, let's move on to the various chapters mentioned above, starting with the artifact -
This is obviously reffering to the Jet Engine - So as a ground rule, there is now a new, tangent universe surrounding the jet engine.
So now for this to make any sense, we need to go and look at the Tangent Universe;
Which directly links to Chapter Six - The Living Receiver
If you can't work out that is referencing to Donnie, you are an idiot. He has numerous of the things mentioned above - while he can not literally just conjour fire and water out of his fingertips, this is what flooding the school and burning Jim Cunningham's house down is obviously meant to symbolise. He is also tormented with the visions, in the form of Frank.
One thing I can't work out for the life of me though is whether or not he succeded in his job of getting the engine back to a position ready for transportation back to the Primary Universe - I'd presume he did though, as while he may of died, the universe was still intact at the end, was it not?
To further confuse you though, you could say the Tangent Universe did end, but the only thing it damaged was him, as he was so directly involved in it - Maybe he was in fact the Tangent Universe, so he was the only thing it would ever affect. Ok, I'm talking gibberish now, but pointless speculation is allways good.
Jesus... I've just realised that the living receiver could well be Frank. While we have no evidence that he suffers from hallucinations or the like, in the way of the other powers, he's actually far more likely than Donnie - let's compare.
No proof in the movie that either have that, so that's Donnie - 0 : Frank - 0
This one is a tad more complicated... Donnie definitely remains at 0, as he never does anything along those lines at all during the entire film. Frank however manages to create a a portal (is it actually a portal? I need to re-watch that bit methinks) to the house - but still, you could say that is not physically moving objects.
I think I'll keep that one as nil nil.
This is where Frank starts pulling ahead - you could easily claim that he uses mindcontrol on Donnie - as, if Frank had not told Donnie to do certain acts, Donnie would not have commited them. I also further believe he is controlling Donnie's mind, as would you/Donnie (normally) just agree to flood a school, or burn down a house? I don't think so.
1 - 0 to Frank.
I'm going to give both characters both points for this one - as NEITHER can conjour directly, but both can conjour through something else. Again, I reference to the house; Frank conjoured fire through Donnie, Donnie conjoured fire with a can of petrol and a match.
3 - 2 to Frank.
So if we ignore the last line of that Chapter, it seems amazing that Frank is actually more likely to be the living receiver than Donnie is... but, the last line outwieghs the rest.
This is the one line that proves the living receiver is Donnie - Donnie is suffering these Hallucinations in the form of Frank, and as such, Frank is merely a figment of his imagination, or is he? Frank could merely be manipulating space-time, so he only appears to Donnie and no-one else, in which case, he would not be a hallucination at all... just immensly clever and complicated.
Though I really don't think that is the case - I believe he is a hallucination, besides, we have no proof that Frank has hallucinations, so yeah. Donnie is the living receiver.
Now we've settled that Donnie is indeed the living receiver, we better move onto the next two chapters.
I presume that's talking about the wormy things that come out of people's bodies, but I can't really confirm that... that has got to be one of the most confusing things I've ever read actually.
Can anyone clarify what that chapter means?
As you can't see the entire page on that one, it kind of doesn't make sense, but I'd presume it's reffering to main of the human race.
Now we have all the ground rules laid down, and a very basic outline of certain stuff, we can actually move onto the plot - which is where it gets complicated.
I'm actually not entirely sure about the plot myself... I thought I was halfway through this version, but the ending, once again, threw me right off the path.
Basically, I think that -
The jet engine has fallen through the fourth dimension and corrupted it, causing a tangent universe. As it happens to fall in his room, Donnie becomes the living receiver - and Frank tries to help him complete his conquest (I believe that the flooding and burning were Frank checking that he really is the living receiver).
Donnie is not actually going insane - Frank may be a hallucination, but Donnie is certainly not losing his mind, and if he is losing it, then insanity is being forced upon him by the Tangent Universe.
The ending is where it gets really, really complex, but I think I have it kind of sussed. Donnie succeds in getting the Artifact ready for the journey back to the Primary Universe, and as such, he has completed his mission. So, when the Tangent Universe comes to an end, it merely rewinds time, and crashes the engine from the Primary Universe, into the Primary Universe that is Donnie's bedroom (as in it never leaves the Primary Universe)... so while he dies, Donnie succeds in his mission, and the universe remains intact.
Wow, god knows why I didn't include this in the original reference points -
118:00 - Chapter Twleve - Dreams.
This chapter basically explains the end, and exactly why time DIDN'T rewind, despite the editing makeing it seem like it did.
So that period of time DID happen, and Donnie dying, and the ending in general was a direct follow on from it - but nobody except Donnie can remember it.
Well, I hope this 1500 word + post cleared some stuff up for somebody, or at the very least kept somebody entertained for a few minutes, as it took more than a bloody hour to write! :lol:
Definitely a spoiler this time!
Ok, Before you read the rest of this, if you're mightily confused and have only seen what I believe is called the prism edition?, watch the 1 disc directors cut - it explains the movie one hell of a lot better... it's better than the prism edition theatrically as well in my opinion.
Right, again, before you go any further, if you have the directors cut one disc edition, it would be a good idea to reference to the following points;
51:15 (Chapter one of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - Description of tangent universe)
57:14 (Chapter two of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - Water and Metal)
62:23 (Chapter seven of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - the manipulated living)
64:02 (Donnie moves through time during Jim Cunninghams' presentation)
69:24 (Chapter four of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - The Artifact And The Living)
72:27 (Chapter six of Roberta Sparrows' book shown - The Living Receiver)
Right, I'm not sure, but I think that is all of them... if somebody knows of an other chapter in the book that is shown and I've missed, please post it.
Now, let's move on to the various chapters mentioned above, starting with the artifact -
Roberta Sparrow said:When a Tangent Universe occurs, those living nearest to the Vortex will find themselves at the epicenter of a dangerous new world.
Artifacts provide the first sign that a Tangent Universe has occured.
If an artifact occurs, the living will retrieve it with great interest and curiosity. Artifacts are formed from metal, such as an Arrowhead from an ancient Mayan civilization, or a Metal Sword from Medieval Europe.
This is obviously reffering to the Jet Engine - So as a ground rule, there is now a new, tangent universe surrounding the jet engine.
So now for this to make any sense, we need to go and look at the Tangent Universe;
Roberta Sparrow said:Incidents when the fabric of the fourth dimension becomes corrupted are incredibly rare.
If a Tangent Universe occurs, it will be highly unstable, sustaining life for no longer than several weeks.
Eventually it will collapse upon itself, forming a black hole within the Primary Universe capable of destroying all existence.
Which directly links to Chapter Six - The Living Receiver
Roberta Sparrow said:The Living Receiver is chosen to guide the Artifact into position for its journey back to the Primary Universe.
No one knows how or why a Receiver will be chosen.
The Living Receiver is often blessed with Fourth Dimensional Powers. These include increased strength, telekenesis, mindcontrol, and the ability to conjour fire and water.
The Living Receiver is often tormented by terrifying dreams, visions and auditory hallucinations during his time within the Tangent Universe.
If you can't work out that is referencing to Donnie, you are an idiot. He has numerous of the things mentioned above - while he can not literally just conjour fire and water out of his fingertips, this is what flooding the school and burning Jim Cunningham's house down is obviously meant to symbolise. He is also tormented with the visions, in the form of Frank.
One thing I can't work out for the life of me though is whether or not he succeded in his job of getting the engine back to a position ready for transportation back to the Primary Universe - I'd presume he did though, as while he may of died, the universe was still intact at the end, was it not?
To further confuse you though, you could say the Tangent Universe did end, but the only thing it damaged was him, as he was so directly involved in it - Maybe he was in fact the Tangent Universe, so he was the only thing it would ever affect. Ok, I'm talking gibberish now, but pointless speculation is allways good.
Jesus... I've just realised that the living receiver could well be Frank. While we have no evidence that he suffers from hallucinations or the like, in the way of the other powers, he's actually far more likely than Donnie - let's compare.
Roberta Sparrow said:These include increased strength,
No proof in the movie that either have that, so that's Donnie - 0 : Frank - 0
Roberta Sparrow said:telekenesis,
This one is a tad more complicated... Donnie definitely remains at 0, as he never does anything along those lines at all during the entire film. Frank however manages to create a a portal (is it actually a portal? I need to re-watch that bit methinks) to the house - but still, you could say that is not physically moving objects.
I think I'll keep that one as nil nil.
Roberta Sparrow said:mindcontrol
This is where Frank starts pulling ahead - you could easily claim that he uses mindcontrol on Donnie - as, if Frank had not told Donnie to do certain acts, Donnie would not have commited them. I also further believe he is controlling Donnie's mind, as would you/Donnie (normally) just agree to flood a school, or burn down a house? I don't think so.
1 - 0 to Frank.
Roberta Sparrow said:and the ability to conjour fire and water.
I'm going to give both characters both points for this one - as NEITHER can conjour directly, but both can conjour through something else. Again, I reference to the house; Frank conjoured fire through Donnie, Donnie conjoured fire with a can of petrol and a match.
3 - 2 to Frank.
So if we ignore the last line of that Chapter, it seems amazing that Frank is actually more likely to be the living receiver than Donnie is... but, the last line outwieghs the rest.
Roberta Sparrow said:The Living Receiver is often tormented by terrifying dreams, visions and auditory hallucinations during his time within the Tangent Universe.
This is the one line that proves the living receiver is Donnie - Donnie is suffering these Hallucinations in the form of Frank, and as such, Frank is merely a figment of his imagination, or is he? Frank could merely be manipulating space-time, so he only appears to Donnie and no-one else, in which case, he would not be a hallucination at all... just immensly clever and complicated.
Though I really don't think that is the case - I believe he is a hallucination, besides, we have no proof that Frank has hallucinations, so yeah. Donnie is the living receiver.
Now we've settled that Donnie is indeed the living receiver, we better move onto the next two chapters.
Roberta Sparrow - Water And Metal (Chapter Two) said:Water and Metal are the key elements of Time Travel.
Water is the barrier element for the construction of Time Portals used as gateways between universes at the Tangent Vortex
I presume that's talking about the wormy things that come out of people's bodies, but I can't really confirm that... that has got to be one of the most confusing things I've ever read actually.
Can anyone clarify what that chapter means?
Roberta Sparrow - The Manipulated Living said:which is to assist the Living Receiver in returning the Artifact to the Primary Universe.
The Manipulated Living will do anything to save themselves from Oblivion
As you can't see the entire page on that one, it kind of doesn't make sense, but I'd presume it's reffering to main of the human race.
Now we have all the ground rules laid down, and a very basic outline of certain stuff, we can actually move onto the plot - which is where it gets complicated.
I'm actually not entirely sure about the plot myself... I thought I was halfway through this version, but the ending, once again, threw me right off the path.
Basically, I think that -
The jet engine has fallen through the fourth dimension and corrupted it, causing a tangent universe. As it happens to fall in his room, Donnie becomes the living receiver - and Frank tries to help him complete his conquest (I believe that the flooding and burning were Frank checking that he really is the living receiver).
Donnie is not actually going insane - Frank may be a hallucination, but Donnie is certainly not losing his mind, and if he is losing it, then insanity is being forced upon him by the Tangent Universe.
The ending is where it gets really, really complex, but I think I have it kind of sussed. Donnie succeds in getting the Artifact ready for the journey back to the Primary Universe, and as such, he has completed his mission. So, when the Tangent Universe comes to an end, it merely rewinds time, and crashes the engine from the Primary Universe, into the Primary Universe that is Donnie's bedroom (as in it never leaves the Primary Universe)... so while he dies, Donnie succeds in his mission, and the universe remains intact.
Wow, god knows why I didn't include this in the original reference points -
118:00 - Chapter Twleve - Dreams.
This chapter basically explains the end, and exactly why time DIDN'T rewind, despite the editing makeing it seem like it did.
Roberta Sparrow - Chapter Twelve - Dreams said:When the Manipulated awaken from their Journey into the Tangent Universe, they are often haunted by the experience in their dreams.
Many of them will not remember.
So that period of time DID happen, and Donnie dying, and the ending in general was a direct follow on from it - but nobody except Donnie can remember it.
Well, I hope this 1500 word + post cleared some stuff up for somebody, or at the very least kept somebody entertained for a few minutes, as it took more than a bloody hour to write! :lol: