Rate the Sig and Avatar - II

[A-Kid]

Now that is cool!

Ava: 8/10 Needs stronger colours.

Sig: 10/10 Love it.

 

[Crow]

Avatar - 7/10

I like it but it would be nice to see more of the train.

Signature - 9/10

Its very, very, nice :--D

 

[Kebab]

Crow

Avatar: 8/10 - It's simple and effective. But thats about it; slightly bland.

Sig: 8/10 - Again; very simplistic and looks a lot more interesting than the avatar. If it wasn't so tall I would have gave it a 9/10, however you should keep to a similar size to everyone elses banners.

Overall I give an 8/10 - A few more colours such as a reds or purples would bring it to a higher rating, and altering the size of the sig would also be considered; very effective and simplistic. Well done.

 

[Uncle Arly]

WMSP wins, so 9/10 for the ava.

I like the sig, but I like sets that match...so 6/10.

I just knocked mine up...

 

[nealbie]

^ What happened to the Wine Gums!?!?! :lol:

7/10 though

 

[Xpress]

Not a big fan of formula 1. Deserves a good 8/10 tho

 

[furie]

They're pretty good actually.
Consistent - check!
Well made - check!
Not coaster related - check!
Not a poor joke - check!

That gives it a 100% matching of my criteria. Well done! Have 9.10 for both (they're good, but not outstanding )

 

[Slash]

Avatar is very original, loving the three generations GIF. It's something very unique.

Your sig, its bloody Epic I LOVE it.

10/10

 

[Ollie]

8/10 for both. Only some of those doughnuts look yummy.

 

[Pokemaniac]

9/10. Same shot used twice, and there's too much going on. Other than that, perfect.

 

[ryan462]

9/10 for both. Unique and looks good

 

[Xpress]

Hmm, good set.

Ava: 8/10

sig: 8/10 (??????)

 

[Blaze]

Never heard of them, but it's good, 7.5/10 for ava, 9/10 for the sig.

 

[Xpress]

^You should check them out. 3 of the members are from Guns N Roses, which was basically the worlds biggest band in the early early 90's.

Ava: pretty decent shot, so a 7/10

Sig: Umm, okay? 7/10

 

[Blaze]

Oh right, sounds interesting now i know that.
To understand the sig you need to have seen the advert, sorry.

 

[Uncle Arly]

I like. 7/10.

 

[Xpress]

Xpress like MO! 8.8/10 for de set.

 

[Inverse]

I don't really like Velvet Revolver, but i'll try and not let that cloud my judgement.

Sig and Ava are well made. Maybe sig is a little tall for my taste, but it needs to be to get everyone in... they should have made Slash and the other guitarist stand on something!

So yeah, 7/10 as it doesn't hold much interest for me.

 

[Kebab]

Simplistic, maybe overly simplistic where use of colours is in concern. The avatar is effective, but the sig is a bit bland.

I'd give the avatar a 7/10 and the sig 5/10

Level it up for an overall of 6/10

 

[Ollie]

Ava: 9/10 nice bright colours, and a very clear picture.
Sig: 8/10 Again really nice colours and it's framed well


I've decided to change my set as I think everyone know I like Saw now.